The Autumn season is always the most problematic for me. School returns, work continues, football devours my weekends, and my free time essentially evaporates. And to make matters more difficult, the Autumn is usually a busy and impressive anime season with numerous impressive shows and other ones deserving of attention. In order to get the most out of this season, it will require some skillful juggling and efficient time management and even then, I doubt I’ll have time to watch all that I want to. There may be some difficult verdicts to make this season, so let’s see what anime might make the cut in this season.
This Autumn features a substantial amount of sequels, more than any other season this year. There is quite an impressive line-up, too, with many well-received and popular anime getting second, third, or even recreations. Predicting how these will do will be easier than most of the new shows since we already have some good ideas of what they’ll be like. However, I haven’t seen all of them and can’t really comment on those that I haven’t seen and don’t plan on starting midway through the series. So that’s all you’ll hear from shows like Fate/Zero, Bakuman 2, Shakugan no Shana III, Mirai Nikki (Future Diary), and Sekai-ichi Hatsukoi (World’s First Love), the four shows I’m not up to date on. I’m positive your opinion on the previous shows, if you watched them, would be better than whatever I would end up saying. That leaves several others which I’ll provide some quick thoughts on:
Shinryaku! Ika Musume (Invasion! Squid Girl) – One of my top-ranked comedies is returning for another season. The first season clicked the entire time for me and I watched every episode, every single moment of it, with a big, stupid smile on my face. While the humor wasn’t the best and the artwork simple, it’s the light-hearted comedy that I have an unashamed soft-spot for. It’s no surprise that this is one of the anime I’m looking forward to the most this Autumn.
Last Exile: Ginyoku no Fam (Last Exile: Fam, the Silver Wing) – While I have yet to even see the first season, I do know I will be watching this series. How do I know? Well, Last Exile is one of the few anime that all my friends have recommended to me with completely enthusiastic and positive reviews. Not many anime get that sort of treatment from my diverse range of anime friends, so that’s what put it in my anime queue. Haven’t had as much time as I wanted this past spring and summer to watch it, and with this season quickly approaching, I’ll make room for myself to marathon it and be all caught up before the first episode airs. I’m sure I’ll love both seasons but I can’t really say too much on this since I’ve refused to research it before finishing the first season.
WORKING’!! – Another comedy that worked well for me in its first season. To be honest, I wasn’t thrilled when I saw it was announced for this season (busiest season of the year for me) but that changed after watching the pre-air episode. It’s not perfect but it’s a series that always has some great laughs in it. And with the lack of comedies this season, I figure I’ll keep it since it will likely be the funniest anime of the season.
Tamayura ~ Hitotose – A four episode OVA of this is already out, so this belongs in the ‘sequel’ section. Like Last Exile, I haven’t watched the first series but I plan on doing so before the season begins. I’m not entirely sure if I’ll keep it like the previous three shows but I do plan on giving it a chance since the OVA has had encouraging reviews. I’ve researched it a bit and scanned through some of the OVA and it appears to be something I’d like. The creator/director of this series also directed Aria, an all-time favorite of mine, which is what originally piqued my interest in this franchise. Will watch the OVA before starting this series but it shouldn’t take as long as Last Exile.
Fujilog 2nd Season – If this is a TV series (24 minute episodes) then no, the first season was weak in comedy and story and I doubt I’d last a full season, let alone a full episode. If they’re like the first season, all 4 minutes episodes, then I can handle it but I doubt it will be better than the first season. That ending theme made the show.
HUNTERxHUNTER – This is a remake of the first series, which seems to be popular with a certain circle of friends. I’m willing to give it a shot to see what the series is like but I usually never last long into shounen anime like this. That and I’m guessing there won’t be enough time each week to keep up with it, but it’s worth a shot.
So there’s about half the season already. Can’t say I enjoy seeing so many sequels in one season since they’re usually never as good as the original but they’re usually better than some of the shit that comes out now. Sequels are always destined to be safe, middle-of-the-road shows unless they can recreate the magic the first season had. I’m guessing those first two will come the closest to reliving their greatness while the others will end up being pretty mediocre to adequate.
But what makes any anime season are the new shows. And there are plenty of impressive ones airing this Autumn which bring promise to this season. As always, there are some gambles and ones that need to be avoided, but it looks like a strong season is before us. Of course, after a few weeks we’ll know how remarkable this season after experiencing all the shows for a few weeks. Let’s see what’s lined up for us:
Guilty Crown
Opinion: Did you watch the PV? Did you? If you answered no, then stop and watch it. If you answered yes, then stop and rewatch it again. The PV does more than any of my words can here. I’ve never seen a more impressive PV for an upcoming anime before. From the animation, to the directing, to the art style, to the concept, and characters, and music, and story, and the noitaminA timeslot, this should easily end up being the top show of the season, both for me and in terms of popularity. I’m anticipating this like no other and even if it ends up disappointing, it will still rank higher than most others this season. An incredible, must-watch anime for any fan.
Plans for this show: Will watch
UN-GO
Opinion: I contemplated having some spaces between Guilty Crown and this but the other noitaminA anime places second in the pre-season rankings despite the sizable gap in impressions by these two. Still, UN-GO looks to another excellent anime with its mystery-themed story and rather effective art style (not overpowering and very clean, as expected from Bones). I was a little weary about the young character with the animal-themed hat and paws until I found out it’s a guy. I’m tired of seeing a serious and intelligent teenage boy paired with a wild and crazy girl of a younger age, so seeing it be a male character reinforces some confidence in this series. Should be another stellar and enjoyable anime from noitaminA.
Plans for this show: Will watch
Persona 4 The Animation
Opinion: Never played the game but I’ve heard so much about it. Appears to be another popular anime for this Autumn with a rather strong following from those who played and loved the game. Everything looks solid about this anime, from the art and animation to the music, and, the directing. Not sure what to think about the story at this point since they are compressing a rather lengthy game into an anime of set length, so hopefully the quality is not lost here. I don’t foresee much wrong with this series and will likely keep it as a show this season.
Plans for this show: Likely watch
Ben-To
Opinion: Ben-To is an anime that will likely surprise me. I haven’t been too impressed with the PVs but have no faults with the animation and art style. The plot seems rather silly, everyone fighting over discounted lunches (you’d figure the medical bills would make these fights economically unfeasible), but it sounds entertaining. I’m not sure how much comedy is in this anime but I hope there’s an adequate amount to keep up with the fighting. If not, I hope the serious style plays well with what’s happening on screen. The one draw-back to this series, at least now, are the characters. They all seemed plain and uninspired. Guess they might look that way from only a few promotional videos, so perhaps I should reserve that comment until the anime actually airs.
Plans for this show: Maybe watch
Chihayafuru
Opinion: I don’t think I can recall any shoujo/sports anime or manga off the top of my head, so this is likely the most original anime of the season. Not sure how well the sports aspect will come out but I’m sure it will be entertaining, even if it’s something simple but dramatic like karuta (the card game Chihaya plays). I figure the drama will be the main focus of the show though which might hurt the show since shoujo drama isn’t typically something I fall for. At least it’s based off the award-winning manga, so that should calm my uncertainties. The art might be the best aspect of the show.
Plans for this show: Maybe watch
Kyoukai Senjou no Horizon (Horizon on the Middle of Nowhere)
Opinion: Anime that blend comedy and fighting together as the two main features usually fare well with me. And the fanservice doesn’t appear to be distracting or annoying, so that’s a plus. But there’s always those few that seem alright at first but end up having awful comedy, predictable fighting, and go overboard on the ecchi. I can’t really give it props there yet but it’s a good sign right now. The setting, with those minute futuristic details, looks rather enjoyable. I think I’ll end up watching and liking this anime, but there are some drawbacks that put it in this category (although it’s above Ben-To in my opinion). For one, I’m not sure if the cast will be all that great when so many appear to be clichés. And another school/academy setting, at least that’s my impression, dampens my overall enthusiasm. But if the comedy and fighting are good and the ecchi not distracting, then I don’t see why this won’t be picked up.
Plans for this show: Maybe watch
Boku wa Tomodachi ga Sukunai (I Don’t Have Many Friends)
Opinion: I love comedies and this appears to be one of the more popular anime of the season, quite an impressive following among my friends, but I can’t shake this sinking feeling I have for this anime. I guess I have that feeling from the obvious harem and school set-ups (two big Xs). The characters don’t seem all that interesting, more that they’re there to be cute and silly than anything tangible. I doubt there’s any depth in the non-main characters besides having a problem that causes them to join the club (not even working to fix their problem, either). It appears to be based on a light-novel, so my expectation for an actual plot are microscopic but that may work if the comedy is hilarious. I watched the OVA with some curiosity and took away some positives (the art, animation, and music are great, definitely watchable), so that helps. But it’s not like it mattered since this anime will be judged mainly on its comedy.
Plans for this show: Doubtful but it gets a shot
C3 – CubexCursedxCurious
Opinion: There are two promotional videos out with two completely different styles to them. The one I linked, the one that is responsible for this ranking, shows some rather remarkable fights with smooth animation and a cast of sensible characters. I’d probably rank it one category above if I watched that PV alone. The second PV, shows the cast of characters be lackluster and ecchi (in a not-so-good way) and is, well, quite terrible. I’d be in the category below if I watched that PV alone. So, as you can see, I’m split; it appears to be both entertaining and abysmal. I’m going to give this anime a go but I doubt I’ll keep it around for the entire season. And I’m starting to doubt that I’ll even last the first episode, too.
Plans for this show: Doubtful but it gets a shot
Kimi to Boku (You and I)
Opinion: Appears to be a slice-of-life around five males in their high school years. Can’t say I have a problem with that set up, especially since it’s centered around males which is quite different than most slice-of-life anime, so those are all positives. But I can’t help but wonder about this anime long-term. I’m sure the first few episodes will be worthwhile but I fear it will begin to get tedious and boring before too long. Guess I should wait to see what the actual content is like but, whenever thinking about this anime, I do worry about starting this anime and not finishing it. Maybe the setbeck will vanish once I start watching this anime but this is the opinion I have of the anime now and that’s why it’s ranking this low.
Plans for this show: Doubtful but it gets a shot
Phi Brain: Kami no Puzzle
Opinion: I like puzzles. They’re like mysteries but straight-forward, quicker, and often times more diverse. So that’s plus. Not sure what to expect from the story or the setting but I figure they’ll be pretty bland, especially since the PV never spent any time on either. So those are negatives. The art/animation was pretty subpar. Another negative. The characters look rather regrettable, both in design and personality. Another negative. But I’m going to end this summary on a positive: I’m going to give it an episode. Let’s see if it can prove me wrong.
Plans for this show: Doubtful but it gets a shot
And below are the shows that proudly wear a big, red X, one that I recently handed them. They have virtually zero chance of being watched by me but at least they’ll be watched by someone else… I’m sorry to whoever has to shoulder that burden.
Maji de Watashi ni Koi Shinasai!!
Opinion: The harem, ecchi, and school set ups are more than enough to turn me off of this anime. And I’m not sure I’d even like the fighting when everyone is already overpowered like that to start.
Plans for this show: No dice
Maken-Ki!
Opinion: The harem, ecchi, and school set ups are blah, blah, blah you know the drill. Surprised it was even more uninteresting than Maji de Watashi ni Koi Shinasai!!
Plans for this show: No dice
Mashiro-Iro Symphony (Pure White Symphony)
Opinion: I seem to have a severe weakness to non-ecchi adaptations of adult visual novels. Even though they have two set-ups I despise in an anime (harem and school), they always appear on my radar. I think I figured it out during Fortune Arterial a few seasons back, though, and that it’s almost entirely due to the character designs in the anime. Well, this one doesn’t appear to have the best character designs, so maybe I can start trying to shake this hypocritical habit of mine. Although watch me break this habit by scanning around the first episode to see what it’s like.
Plans for this show: No dice
Mobile Suit Gundam AGE
Opinion: Those character designs and dragons (or whatever) are a turn-off. I’ll let someone else tell me how it is.
Plans for this show: No dice
So that ends this Autumn season preview. I’m not sure how many anime I’ll end up watching this season but it will likely be the least since I started blogging. And even then, some shows may get delayed or put on hold depending on what happens with school and work, so there’s a fairly large amount of uncertainty heading into this season. But still, I can’t wait to see what surprises, disappointments, memorable moments, laughs, twists, and history will be made this season. I just hope to be a part of it all. So with all that said and done, let these next thirteen weeks be an absolute blast!
#1 by tsurugiarashix on September 23, 2011 - 9:15 AM
Already have 18 series on my list. But like you, school work and the interest factor may leave me to save them for another period of time to watch. Right now, trying to finish my infinite backlog, lol.
#2 by avvesione on September 23, 2011 - 6:32 PM
Yeah, I’d love to watch 15 this autumn like I’m doing this season (including those carrying over from this summer) that’s just not being realistic. I think I’ll be watching around 7-8 and maybe save some others for later. Can’t really put them in my backlog since I haven’t touched it since… wow, last Autumn…
#3 by zammael on September 23, 2011 - 9:30 AM
Grad School for me too. Good bye Anime time! :( But I’ll be following 3 or 4 shows at most!
#4 by avvesione on September 23, 2011 - 6:34 PM
Well, I hope you follow the 3-4 best shows of the season. Do we have similar choices this season or is there something else you’re looking forward to that I’m not?
#5 by zammael on September 25, 2011 - 6:38 PM
I don’t have any choices of my own. Probably because I don’t trust synopses by marketing folks. Just please, anything of high caliber like Steins; Gate or Penguin Drum! Nothing shitty like Kami-Sama no Memo-Cho or mediocre like Hana Saku Iroha, por favor, senor.
#6 by avvesione on September 25, 2011 - 7:52 PM
Guess we’ll find out. Good luck selecting your shows this season!
#7 by Justin on September 23, 2011 - 7:17 PM
Uh-oh:
“And below are the shows that proudly wear a big, red X, one that I recently handed them. They have virtually zero chance of being watched by me but at least they’ll be watched by someone else… I’m sorry to whoever has to shoulder that burden–”
Dude, I’m required to watch three episodes of works that have a 10% of being good! Well don’t worry. I’ll tell you if those animes (especially not Gundam Age) are good or not.
And as for Gundam Age, it has to be more than the characters and dragons to turn you off. You could have just said “It’s Gundam!” :D
#8 by avvesione on September 23, 2011 - 7:33 PM
Good luck watching three episodes of everything to start. I cannot do that since there are too many anime I just give up on after one episode, trying to relive that undesirable experience two more times would be meaningless. But you really give your anime a fair chance which is something I don’t do.
As for Gundam, I’ll keep my ears out to hear what people think but it’s not something that interests me like all the shows above it. And even if I did watch it and like it, I’d probably have to cut it since I’m scaling back the amount of anime I’m watching to accommodate school/work/football/etc. I’ll check out what you have to say about it after it airs.
#9 by FaS on September 23, 2011 - 7:50 PM
Yeah…you know for some reason I don’t have patience anymore for looking at EVERY Show description to see if I want to watch because after the first 3 that look dumb…your hope for good shows deflates ever so much. I still haven’t looked at what guilty crown is reeaaaalllly about, but I mean come on, the name screams production value. Anyways, Ben-to sounds really stupid and I’m hoping it won’t just be cheap laughs & stupid nosebleeds. Mmm other anime…idk..I’ll have to check out fate/stay night in the first place since I haven’t even seen it :p
#10 by avvesione on September 24, 2011 - 12:21 AM
Yeah, it is difficult and time-consuming to track down every anime each season but some people (as you can read above comments) enjoy doing that since they can really find the best. I think what might be best is to try a few you think are the best and later, after a week or so, find an opinion of someone you’re pretty similar with and see what they think about the others. I keep my eyes and ears out for everything each season for the first few weeks in case some of these opinions are completely wrong. And it helps prevent that deflation in enthusiasm you mentioned after watching some poor shows. HTH
And I think one of the reasons I’m looking forward to Ben-To is that it sounds ridiculous. Hope it can pull that off while being fun and entertaining.
#11 by Justin on September 23, 2011 - 9:04 PM
Haha–there’s one problem about the Gundam thing–I won’t be actually writing about it when I do my first impressions. It’s part of the “Established Franchise” jurisdiction that prevents me from writing about it. I’ll just have to tell you by tongue and cheek. Or something like that!
#12 by avvesione on September 24, 2011 - 12:23 AM
Ah dang. Well, I’ll keep my eyes out for any news on Gundam AGE since it’s one of the ones I’m the most curious about. I’m sure there’ll be two camps immediately with those who love it and those who hate it (based off prior Gundam experience or on PV material alone), so it might be tough finding an unbiased opinion in the first few weeks.
#13 by Detetiv on September 25, 2011 - 7:14 PM
Hmmm, maybe Persona 4 will be similar to the manga version in terms of length? So far it’s about 4 volumes though I think I’ve only read 2 volumes [All I can remember the last person they needed to save was hiding in a castle]
#14 by avvesione on September 25, 2011 - 7:57 PM
Four volumes sounds about right for a 12-episode anime but I wouldn’t be surprised if they tried to do something different here. I suppose you’ll be aware if the anime follows the manga since you’ve read some of it. I have zero knowledge of the game or manga, so whatever happens will be exciting and original for me.
#15 by Detetiv on September 28, 2011 - 3:57 AM
Knowing myself I have to re-read it again cause I was reading the original Persona & Persona 3 manga at the time. [Just happy that they didn’t make it a mess of the storyline like Persona 3]